Gamegenic Squire Plus vs. Squire: Which Deck Box Fits Your Commander Deck?

Quick Answer

If you double-sleeve your Commander deck with thick inner sleeves, choose the Gamegenic Squire 100+ XL Convertible. If you use standard single sleeves or thinner double sleeves, the original Squire (80+ XL) may be enough, but note that the Squire Plus is a different line. For most double-sleeved Commander decks, the 100+ XL is the safer fit.

Choosing the right deck box for your Commander deck is about more than looks—it's about fit. A box that's too tight can bend cards or make shuffling a chore. Gamegenic offers several Squire models, and the difference between the Squire Plus and the standard Squire can be confusing.

In this comparison, we'll break down the key differences between the Gamegenic Squire Plus (often referring to the 100+ XL Convertible) and the standard Squire (like the Deck Holder 100+). You'll learn what fits, what doesn't, and how to decide based on your sleeve setup.

Understanding the Squire Line

Gamegenic's Squire line is known for compact, sturdy deck boxes that protect your cards during transport and play. The standard Squire deck boxes, like the Deck Holder 100+, are designed for up to 100 double-sleeved cards, but with a standard fit. They feature a self-locking flap and a write-on strip for labeling, making them a solid budget-friendly choice.

The Squire Plus, however, refers to the 'Convertible' line, which includes the Squire 100+ XL. This version is explicitly made to fit 100 double-sleeved cards in particularly thick inner sleeves. The 'XL' designation means extra space for those thicker sleeves or additional tokens. This is a crucial distinction if you use premium inner sleeves.

• Check your inner sleeve thickness: if you use standard inner sleeves, a regular 100+ box may work; if you use thick ones, go XL.

Key Differences: Size and Capacity

The most important difference is the internal dimensions. The Squire 100+ XL Convertible is specifically designed to hold 100 double-sleeved cards in thick inner sleeves, with room left over for tokens. The regular Deck Holder 100+ also holds 100 double-sleeved cards, but it's not optimized for thick inner sleeves—so if your sleeves are on the thicker side, the cards might be a tight squeeze.

Another difference is the opening mechanism. The Squire 100+ XL uses a 'Convertible' design, which means the lid can be clipped to the bottom for easy access during play. The Deck Holder 100+ uses a self-locking flap with Cobra Neck technology, allowing a 180° opening. Both are convenient, but the Convertible design is more innovative if you like to keep the lid out of the way.

• If you use thick inner sleeves, always measure your deck's thickness before buying—don't assume '100+ cards' means it will fit any sleeve combo.

Price and Value

Price is a major factor. The Deck Holder 100+ is a casual deck box with a price of $1.74 (compare at $3.49), making it an extremely affordable option. The Squire 100+ XL Convertible, on the other hand, is a premium deck box at $12.50 (compare at $24.99). That's a significant price difference.

What do you get for the extra money? The Squire 100+ XL is built with premium materials and a more robust closure, plus the convertible lid feature. It's designed for long-term durability and a more secure fit for thicker sleeves. If you're a casual player who just needs a box for a single-sleeved deck, the Deck Holder 100+ is a great value. If you're a dedicated Commander player with a heavily blinged-out deck, the investment in the XL is worth it.

Trade-offs at a Glance

• Squire 100+ XL Convertible: Premium price, but offers extra space for thick inner sleeves and tokens. Convertible lid design for easy access. Best for players who double-sleeve with thick sleeves and want a durable, premium box.
• Deck Holder 100+: Very affordable, but standard fit may be tight with thick inner sleeves. Lacks the convertible lid feature. Best for budget-conscious players with single or standard double-sleeved decks.
• Consider your sleeve thickness: If you're unsure, measure your deck. A standard 100-card double-sleeved deck can vary by several millimeters depending on the sleeve brand. When in doubt, choose the XL version to avoid a tight fit.

Product Facts

• SQUIRE100+ XL CONVERTIBLE: Made to fit 100 double-sleeved cards in particularly thick Inner Sleeves. Exclusive extra-large version that holds 100 regular double-sleeved cards and has extra space for additional tokens. If you use thick inner sleeves (like Dragon Shield or KMC Perfect Hard), this box ensures your deck won't be cramped, and you can even store tokens with it.
• DECK HOLDER 100+: Casual deck box to safely protect up to 100 double-sleeved cards. Self-locking flap closure with Cobra Neck technology, opens up to 180°. Includes a Flex Card Divider. This is a budget-friendly option that works for standard double-sleeved decks, but it may not accommodate thicker inner sleeves. The divider helps organize sideboards or tokens.

Which Should You Choose?

Best For

• Commander players using thick inner sleeves (e.g., Dragon Shield, KMC Perfect Hard) who want a secure, premium fit.
• Players who like to store tokens alongside their deck and prefer the convertible lid feature.

Not For

• Budget players who use single sleeves or standard thin inner sleeves—the Deck Holder 100+ offers better value.
• Those who need a box for multiple decks—consider the Triple Deck Holder 300+ XL instead.

In the end, the choice between the Gamegenic Squire Plus (100+ XL) and the standard Squire (Deck Holder 100+) comes down to your sleeve setup and budget. If you've invested in thick inner sleeves for your Commander deck, the extra space and premium build of the 100+ XL are worth it. If you're a casual player with a simpler setup, the Deck Holder 100+ gets the job done without breaking the bank. Measure your deck, consider your sleeves, and pick the box that gives your cards the protection they deserve.